GreenLine

PUBLIC LAW

Challenging and resolving decisions of the Isle of Man authorities

About our public law services


Decisions by Isle of Man Government departments, statutory boards, regulators and tribunals can have serious consequences for a business or an individual: a licence refused, a permission delayed, a regulatory sanction imposed, or a decision made without proper process. Kinley Legal advises businesses, investors and private clients who need to influence, challenge or resolve those decisions.

Qualified in both systems

Isle of Man public law applies principles of administrative law developed largely in England and Wales, through procedures that are distinctively Manx, including the petition of doleance under the Rules of the High Court of Justice 2009. Our practice is led by Christopher Kinley, an Isle of Man advocate with rights of audience in the Isle of Man courts, who is also admitted as a solicitor in England and Wales, Ireland and Northern Ireland. That combination allows us to advise on both the substance of a challenge and the Manx procedure for bringing it.

Much of our everyday work already involves the decisions of Isle of Man public bodies, in particular the Immigration Service, the Department for Enterprise and the work permit system, and the statutory framework within which they operate. We understand how those decisions are made, where they tend to go wrong, and how to engage with the departments concerned.

Who we advise

We advise companies, regulated businesses, international groups and their directors, and investors, senior executives and families whose plans depend on a government decision. We take on public law matters where the decision has significant commercial, financial or personal consequences.

How we can help

Before a decision is made, we can prepare representations and consultation responses, and engage with departments and regulators so that the decision-maker has the right information and follows a fair process. Where a decision has gone wrong, a carefully prepared letter before action will often resolve matters without proceedings.

Where proceedings are needed, we advise on and bring petitions of doleance, the Isle of Man equivalent of judicial review, to challenge decisions that are unlawful, unreasonable or procedurally unfair, and cases of unreasonable delay or failure to decide. We also advise on statutory appeals where legislation provides a specific right of appeal, on arguments under the Human Rights Act 2001, and on freedom of information and data subject access requests to obtain the material behind a decision.

Decisions we can advise on

Immigration and entry clearance (including delay), work permits, financial services and gambling regulation, licensing, planning and development, public procurement, Treasury decisions, and financial restrictions and sanctions-related decisions.

Our approach

Public law remedies are subject to strict time limits and are discretionary, so early advice matters. We give a clear view of the merits, costs and likely timescale at the outset, pursue a negotiated outcome where one is realistic, and take matters to court where it is not.

Contact us

If a decision affecting you or your business is expected, or has already been made, contact us promptly. Initial consultations are with a senior lawyer. They are charged, and we will confirm the fee when you book. Following the consultation, we will provide a written fee proposal.

Contact Us

To discuss instructing us, call +44 (0)1624 640366, email contact@kinleylegal.com or complete our enquiry form. Initial consultations are with a senior lawyer, in person in Douglas or by video or telephone. They are charged, and we will confirm the fee when you book.

Follow us on LinkedIn and Facebook for updates on Isle of Man law and practice.